When a cyber insurance renewal asks about MFA, it is usually asking three separate questions: is multifactor authentication required for email, for remote access, and for administrator accounts. A yes has to be true for every account in each group, and you have to be able to prove it after a claim.

This guide explains what the questions mean, what counts as MFA, how to turn it on in Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace, what evidence to keep, and who can help a nonprofit in Washington, DC get to an honest yes. Sources were checked on November 18, 2026.

What do cyber insurers ask about MFA?

Applications ask about MFA in three places: email, remote access such as a VPN or Remote Desktop, and administrator accounts. Marsh's 2022 list of twelve key cyber controls sets the scope the same way: everything reachable remotely, all privileged and administrative users, and access to sensitive data.

ETTE's Cyber Insurance Readiness Check treats MFA on email, remote access and administrator accounts as conditions of coverage. Carriers decline or restrict policies over those answers, where weaker answers elsewhere mostly change the price.

Does MFA have to cover every user?

Yes. When a form says all users or all email access, one unprotected account makes the answer no. The accounts that get missed are rarely staff mailboxes:

  • Shared mailboxes and generic accounts such as info@ or scanner@ that someone can sign in to directly.
  • Board members, volunteers and contractors with an account on your domain.
  • Old accounts of people who left.
  • Older mail protocols. Microsoft notes that legacy authentication such as IMAP and POP3 does not support MFA, so an attacker can use it to bypass an MFA policy unless it is blocked.
  • The emergency administrator account kept for lockouts.

What counts as MFA on an insurance application?

A second proof of identity on top of the password: an authenticator app prompt or code, a passkey, a hardware security key, or Windows Hello for Business. A password plus a security question is not MFA.

Not all second factors are equal. Microsoft recommends phishing-resistant methods, meaning passkeys, FIDO2 security keys, Windows Hello for Business or certificate-based authentication, because text-message codes and app codes can be stolen by a fake sign-in page. If your form only asks whether MFA is on, an authenticator app satisfies it. Use the stronger methods for administrators and finance staff anyway.

How do you turn on MFA in Microsoft 365?

There are two supported ways, and which one you can use depends on your license.

  • Security defaults are available on every plan at no extra cost. They require all users to register for MFA, require administrators to use it at every sign-in, prompt other users when Microsoft judges it necessary, and block legacy authentication.
  • Conditional Access lets you write the rule yourself, for example MFA for all users on every sign-in. It requires Microsoft Entra ID P1, which Microsoft 365 Business Premium and E3 include. Security defaults must be turned off before Conditional Access policies are used.

Our view: if you have Business Premium, use a Conditional Access policy that requires MFA for all users. It is easier to evidence than security defaults, because the policy itself states the rule the insurer is asking about.

One point causes confusion. Microsoft now requires MFA for its admin portals, including the Azure portal, the Microsoft Entra admin center and the Microsoft 365 admin center. That covers people signing in to manage the tenant. It does not put MFA on staff email, so it does not answer the insurer's first question.

How do you turn on MFA in Google Workspace?

Google calls it 2-Step Verification. An administrator turns it on for the domain and then enforces it, so that nobody can sign in without it. Google's security checklist recommends enforcing security keys at least for administrators and other high-value accounts.

What evidence should you keep?

Collect it on the day you sign the application, because that is the date a carrier will ask about after a claim.

  • In Microsoft 365, the Authentication methods activity report lists each user and whether they are MFA capable. Export it, along with a copy of the Conditional Access policy or the security defaults setting.
  • In Google Workspace, export the Admin console's user security report, which shows 2-Step Verification enrollment and enforcement.
  • For remote access, keep the VPN or remote desktop configuration showing MFA is required, or a statement that no remote access is allowed.
  • Keep a dated list of any exceptions and why they exist.

Microsoft Entra ID keeps most audit data for only 30 days, so a report you did not export may not exist when you need it.

What happens if you answer yes and it is not true?

The application becomes part of the policy, so an inaccurate yes is a material misrepresentation. After an incident, the carrier's forensic team checks whether the control was in place on the day of the loss. If MFA was not enforced everywhere, the carrier can deny that claim or rescind the policy. When you are not sure, answer no and fix it before renewal.

Who can help with a cyber insurance MFA question in Washington, DC?

Two people, for two different jobs. Your broker tells you what the carrier means by each question and what a no will cost. Your IT provider puts the control in place and produces the evidence. For a nonprofit of 10 to 75 people the technical change is small. The time goes to enrolling every person and finding the accounts nobody owns.

ETTE is a managed IT provider in Washington, DC that has served nonprofits and associations since 2002, with CISSP and CISA certified engineers. For every managed client we enforce MFA and Conditional Access, run monitored endpoint detection and response, manage immutable backups with documented restore tests, and keep patching on a 30-day cadence, which are four of the five conditions of coverage the readiness check tests for. Managed plans start at $125 per user per month remote-only and $150 fully managed, with nonprofit pricing available.

Take the free Cyber Insurance Readiness Check to see all fourteen controls carriers ask about, read what insurers look for in a cyber insurance risk assessment, see how a Virtual CISO handles the application with you, or talk with an advisor at 202-345-1965.

Vendor and carrier guidance in this article was checked against Microsoft, Google and Marsh pages on November 18, 2026. Application wording differs by carrier and changes at renewal. Confirm what your own form asks with your broker.